Talk with Hippasus

Hippasus of Metapontum was an ancient Greek philosopher who lived during the 5th century BCE. He is often associated with the Pythagorean School, founded by Pythagoras. This school combined elements of philosophy, religion, and mathematical theories to form an influential and somewhat secretive community.

Hippasus is most famously credited with the discovery of irrational numbers. According to tradition, he discovered that the square root of 2 could not be expressed as a fraction, which contradicted the Pythagorean belief that all numbers could be expressed as ratios of integers. This discovery is said to have led to significant disputes within the Pythagorean community. According to one legend, Hippasus was drowned at sea by his fellow Pythagoreans as a punishment for divulging this secret, which they felt should be kept within the community.

Hippasus also contributed to developments in musical theory and geometry. He is sometimes credited with the discovery of the dodecahedron, a twelve-faced polyhedron, but this attribution is uncertain. Overall, his contributions are vital in the areas of mathematics and philosophy, particularly for challenging and extending the understanding of numerical concepts in ancient Greece.

Hippasus’s approach to mathematics incorporated both theoretical and practical elements. He is most famously associated with the discovery of irrational numbers, which was a significant theoretical advancement. This discovery likely arose from examining the geometric problem of the square root of 2, particularly in the context of constructing square sides of specific lengths – a problem practical in nature as it relates to geometry and architecture.

Furthermore, as a member of the Pythagorean school, Hippasus's work would also have been influenced by Pythagorean interests in mathematics as a means to understand the cosmos and philosophy, indicating a blend of theoretical exploration with practical applications, especially in contexts like music and astronomy. Thus, his mathematical pursuits likely spanned both theoretical inquiries and their practical uses.

Yes, Hippasus was a member of the Pythagorean Brotherhood. This was a philosophical and religious community founded by Pythagoras in the 6th century BCE. Members of this group were known for their belief in mathematical concepts as the ultimate reality and their strict adherence to various mystical, philosophical, and mathematical principles. Hippasus is notable within this community, particularly for his contributions to the understanding of irrational numbers, which allegedly led to controversy within the group.

Hippasus, a philosopher of the Pythagorean school, viewed numbers with a mystical significance, aligning with the Pythagorean belief that all things are, at their essence, numerable and that the universe could be understood through numbers. Numbers and numerical ratios were seen as the fundamental building blocks of the world, governing everything from the harmonics of music to the proportions of architecture and the orbits of celestial bodies.

However, Hippasus is famously credited with discovering irrational numbers—numbers that cannot be expressed as a simple fraction of two integers. This discovery is sometimes said to have disrupted the Pythagorean notion that all numbers and their relations could be understood through ratios of whole numbers. If Hippasus did indeed make this discovery, his view on the nature of numbers would include the existence of these irrational numbers, adding a layer of complexity to the Pythagorean numerical mysticism and possibly indicating that the universe’s arithmetic structure was more intricate than previously thought.

It is uncertain whether Hippasus received any notable recognition during his lifetime. Historical records on this aspect are sparse. Hippasus is primarily known from the stories and accounts written after his lifetime, which focus mainly on his contributions to mathematics and alleged conflict with the Pythagorean Brotherhood over his discoveries, such as the irrationality of the square root of 2. These accounts do not provide comprehensive details on any recognition or accolades he might have received during his lifetime.

Hippasus did not question the Pythagorean theorem itself, which states that in a right triangle, the square of the length of the hypotenuse is equal to the sum of the squares of the lengths of the other two sides (a² + b² = c²). Instead, his inquiries were more foundational and profound, concerning the nature of numbers and mathematical concepts.

Hippasus is perhaps best known for his discovery of irrational numbers, which challenged the Pythagorean belief that all numbers could be expressed as the ratio of two integers (rational numbers). While studying the properties of geometric figures, he reportedly discovered that the diagonal of a square is not commensurable with its side, meaning their ratio cannot be expressed as a fraction of two whole numbers. This discovery was significant since it contradicted the Pythagorean ideal of the universe being explicable entirely through rational numbers and harmonious proportions.

This led not so much to a questioning of the Pythagorean theorem itself, but rather to a deep philosophical crisis among the Pythagoreans regarding the nature of numbers and their prior understanding of the cosmos. This indicates Hippasus's role in broadening the understanding of mathematical principles rather than disputing specific theorems.

Iamblichus, a Neoplatonist philosopher from the 3rd century AD, wrote about Hippasus in the context of the history of Pythagoreanism. According to Iamblichus, Hippasus was a Pythagorean philosopher who allegedly divulged the secret of the irrationality of the square root of 2, a mathematical discovery supposedly held sacred by the Pythagorean community. Iamblichus mentions that this act led to severe consequences for Hippasus, including possibly his death at sea, which was viewed by the Pythagoreans as a divine punishment for his disclosure of esoteric knowledge.

Additionally, Iamblichus discusses the contributions and role of Hippasus within the Pythagorean sect, although the details might be mixed with legends and the interpretations of later scholars. The story as narrated by Iamblichus has contributed to the mythical aura surrounding Hippasus and the early Pythagoreans, emphasizing the mystical and secretive nature of their philosophical pursuits.

Yes, Hippasus is credited with the discovery of irrational numbers. He was a member of the Pythagorean cult, which revered numbers and the idea that all things could be explained with rational numbers (those that can be expressed as a fraction of two integers). According to legend, Hippasus discovered that the square root of 2 could not be expressed as a fraction, thereby uncovering the existence of irrational numbers. This discovery was said to be shocking to the Pythagoreans and is a significant milestone in the history of mathematics.

Discover and learn about people that are similar to Hippasus.