Talk with René Girard

René Girard (1923–2015) was a French historian, literary critic, and philosopher of social science whose work has had a significant influence across various disciplines, including anthropology, sociology, psychology, theology, and philosophy. He is best known for developing the concept of mimetic theory, a theory that explores the roots of violence and conflict in human societies.

Girard's insights began to coalesce with his first major work, "Deceit, Desire, and the Novel" (1961), where he explored the concept of mimetic desire. According to Girard, mimetic desire refers to the human tendency to desire things because others desire them, leading to rivalry and conflict. As people imitate each other's desires, they often come into conflict over the objects of desire, which are seen as valuable precisely because they are desired by others.

Girard further developed his theories in subsequent works such as "Violence and the Sacred" (1972) and "Things Hidden Since the Foundation of the World" (1978), where he introduced the concept of the scapegoat mechanism. In his view, societies resolve internal tensions and conflicts through the scapegoating process, where a person or group is collectively blamed and expelled or destroyed, thus restoring social harmony temporarily.

Through his theory, Girard proposed that the origin of religion and culture lies in these mimetic conflicts and their resolution through scapegoating, which he argued is evidenced in various cultural myths and rituals across societies. His work also delves into biblical texts, proposing that the Judeo-Christian tradition reveals the arbitrary nature of scapegoating and offers a way out of the cycle of violence.

Girard's theories have been controversial and have provoked debate, but they also have found application in various fields, including conflict resolution, literary criticism, and theological studies. He was elected to the Académie Française in 2005, a testament to his significant impact on intellectual thought.

René Girard's work, while primarily anthropological and philosophical in nature, intersects with psychoanalytic theories, particularly in his exploration of desire and violence. His concept of mimetic desire has parallels with psychoanalytic ideas, although Girard himself was not a psychoanalyst and often critiqued certain aspects of Freudian psychoanalysis.

1. Mimetic Desire: Girard's theory of mimetic desire posits that human desires are not inherently individual or autonomous, but are derived from the desires of others. This is somewhat analogous to the psychoanalytic notion of identification, where an individual unconsciously incorporates traits or desires from another person into their own psyche.

2. Role of the Other: In both Girard's mimetic theory and in psychoanalysis, the 'Other' plays a crucial role in the formation of identity and desire. For Girard, the Other is essential as the model or mediator of desire. In psychoanalysis, the Other can be an authority figure or an internalized other in the psyche, critical in the development of the self.

3. Oedipal Complex and Scapegoating: Girard’s ideas about conflict and rivalry have a distant echo in Freud’s Oedipal complex, where desire for the mother and rivalry with the father are pivotal. Similarly, Girard’s notion of the scapegoat mechanism, where a community projects its violence onto a chosen individual or group, can be connected to psychoanalytic theories of projection and displacement.

4. Critiques of Freud: Despite these parallels, Girard is often critical of certain Freudian concepts. He challenges the Freudian notion of the unconscious's biology-based desires, arguing instead for cultural and mimetic frameworks of understanding desire. Girard also critiques the Freudian emphasis on sexuality as the primary motivator of human behavior, instead positing imitation (mimesis) as more fundamental.

5. Violence and the Sacred: Girard’s exploration of violence and the sacred touches on themes in psychoanalysis related to taboo and the social structures that arise to manage intra-group tensions and aggressions.

In summary, while Girard's theories intersect with psychoanalytic ideas in the realms of desire, identity, and social dynamics, his unique contributions emphasize mimetic desire and cultural factors as drivings forces in human behavior, challenging and expanding upon traditional psychoanalytic perspectives.

René Girard's background had a significant influence on the development of his theoretical ideas. Born in France in 1923 and later moving to the United States, Girard's exposure to a variety of academic environments played a key role in shaping his perspectives.

Initially, Girard studied medieval history at the École des Chartes in Paris, a discipline that emphasizes the analysis and understanding of historical texts. This rigorous training in historical and philological methods likely contributed to his meticulous approach to texts and his interest in the patterns of human behavior and culture over time.

After moving to the United States in 1947, Girard pursued a more diverse academic career, teaching French literature at Indiana University, and later at Johns Hopkins and SUNY Buffalo before settling at Stanford University. His immersion in literary studies exposed him to a broad range of literary texts and traditions. This exposure was crucial in the development of his central idea of "mimetic desire" — the concept that human desires are imitative and that individuals desire objects not for their intrinsic value but because others desire them.

His deep engagement with both literature and history allowed him to cross traditional academic boundaries, applying his theory of mimetic desire not only to literature but also to anthropology, sociology, religious studies, and philosophical anthropology. This interdisciplinary approach helped Girard develop a comprehensive theory that addresses fundamental aspects of human behavior and culture.

Furthermore, his experience in the intellectual climate of post-war America, where there was a burgeoning interest in psychoanalysis and structuralism, likely influenced his approach to cultural and psychological phenomena. The intellectual milieu provided Girard the tools and context necessary to synthesize ideas across disciplines, ultimately leading to his formulation of theories like the scapegoat mechanism and the foundational role of violence in human societies.

Overall, Girard's diverse academic background and his transatlantic experiences significantly shaped his theoretical developments, equipping him with a unique perspective that bridged European and American scholarly traditions.

René Girard's intellectual journey was influenced by several key figures across various disciplines, but particularly by philosophers and anthropologists. Among the most notable influences were:

1. Sigmund Freud - Girard was influenced by Freud's theories on human psychology, particularly ideas related to desire and unconscious motivations, although Girard would eventually part with many aspects of Freudian theory, particularly the sexual focus, to develop his own mimetic theory.

2. Fyodor Dostoevsky - While not a philosopher in the traditional sense, the Russian novelist had a profound influence on Girard’s thinking. Girard considered Dostoevsky’s novels as profound examinations of human desire, mimetic rivalry, and the scapegoat mechanism.

3. Friedrich Nietzsche - Nietzsche’s ideas about the origins of culture and his critique of Christian morality influenced Girard, especially in how Nietzsche dealt with the themes of resentment and what Girard would call mimetic desire.

4. Claude Lévi-Strauss - The anthropological work of Lévi-Strauss, particularly his studies on myths and his structural approach to human cultures, shaped Girard’s thoughts on myth, ritual, and social structures.

5. Georges Bataille - Bataille’s focus on the themes of eroticism, sacrifice, and taboo also touched on areas relevant to Girard’s interest in violence and the sacred.

These thinkers provided a framework from which Girard developed his unique ideas, particularly his theory of mimetic desire, which posits that human desire is not for objects as such but is imitative of the desires of others. This insight led him to explore the implications of such mimetic structures in phenomena ranging from violence and conflict to religion and literature.

René Girard's theory, particularly his concept of mimetic desire, offers profound insights into the nature of human relationships. According to Girard, much of human behavior and desire is not autonomously generated but is rather mimetic—that is, we imitate the desires of others. This imitation can be subconscious and involves not just tangible objects but aspirations, goals, and even traits of others.

In the context of human relationships, this mimetic process can lead to conflict and competition as individuals come to desire the same things that others appear to value or possess. This rivalry can strain or break relationships unless it is recognized and managed.

Moreover, Girard discusses the role of the scapegoat mechanism in his theory, which also has implications for human relationships. When mimetic desires lead to escalating rivalry and conflict, communities may unconsciously transfer their collective aggression onto a scapegoat—an individual or group blamed for various problems regardless of their actual culpability. This act of scapegoating can temporarily restore harmony but at the cost of justice and the well-being of the scapegoat.

Thus, according to Girard, while human relationships are capable of deep affinity and cooperation, they are also fraught with potential for rivalry, conflict, and violence rooted in our mimetic nature. Understanding and mitigating these dynamics is crucial for healthier interpersonal and societal relationships.

Yes, René Girard's theories, especially his concept of mimetic desire, can indeed be applied to modern social media dynamics. Mimetic desire suggests that people desire objects or goals not for their intrinsic value but because they are desired by others. This framework can help in understanding various phenomena on social media platforms.

For instance, the viral nature of trends on social media can be seen as a manifestation of mimetic desire. Users often engage in behaviors, adopt styles, or purchase items that they see popularized by others, particularly influencers or peers, indicating the mimetic nature of their desires.

Furthermore, Girard's discussion of scapegoating can also be relevant in the context of social media. Online conflicts often involve the blaming of an individual or a group for broader social issues, and these individuals can become scapegoats within online communities. This process can intensify conflicts and lead to cycles of reprisal and counter-reprisal, akin to the mimetic violence Girard describes.

Thus, Girard's ideas provide a useful lens through which to analyze interaction patterns and conflicts on social media, highlighting the underlying mimetic structures and their consequences.

René Girard had three children. Their names are Martin, Marie-Hélène, and Pascal.

René Girard held the Bible in high regard, considering it a central text in revealing the mechanisms of human violence and the scapegoat mechanism. His perspective was not merely religious or theological in a conventional sense; instead, he approached the Bible through his anthropological and philosophical theories on mimetic desire and violence.

Girard saw the Bible as unique among religious texts because it provides a clear denunciation of the cycle of violence and the scapegoat mechanism that he believed underpins human societies. In his view, biblical texts gradually unveil the innocence of the scapegoat and the unjust nature of violence directed towards them. This is a revelation that contrasts with many mythologies and religious texts that justify and conceal the violence against scapegoats.

For example, in the Hebrew Bible, the story of Joseph being sold into slavery by his jealous brothers shows the dynamics of mimetic rivalry and scapegoating, yet it also moves towards reconciliation and the revelation of unjust acts. In the Christian New Testament, Girard interpreted the crucifixion of Jesus Christ as the ultimate disclosure of the scapegoat mechanism; Jesus is the innocent victim, whose death exposes and undermines the cycle of mimetic violence.

Thus, Girard viewed the Bible as a text that exposes the truth about human violence and offers a way out through the recognition of this cycle and through paths toward forgiveness and reconciliation. This perspective integrates Girard's scholarly insights with his personal faith, as he was a practicing Roman Catholic. Through this lens, the Bible is not just a religious scripture but a foundational document that challenges the violence inherent in human culture.

René Girard had a profound impact on the field of social sciences through his exploration of concepts such as mimetic desire, scapegoating, and violence. His theories, primarily developed through an interdisciplinary approach that combines anthropology, sociology, psychology, and literary criticism, offer unique insights into human behavior and social organization.

1. Mimetic Desire: Girard's theory of mimetic desire posits that human desires are not inherently autonomous or original but are imitated from others. This concept has been influential in explaining the dynamics of human relationships and social conflict, suggesting that competition and rivalry are often the result of mirrored desires. Social scientists have found this idea particularly useful in examining consumer behavior, social media dynamics, and conflict studies.

2. Scapegoating Mechanism: Girard's scapegoat theory explores how communities tend to transfer their collective aggression onto a chosen victim to maintain social harmony. This idea has been influential in the study of social and political structures, helping analyze phenomena such as racism, discrimination, and political tension. It provides a framework for understanding how societies may handle internal conflicts and stresses by projecting them onto an outsider or marginalized group.

3. Violence and the Sacred: In his work, Girard discusses the intimate relationship between violence and sacred rituals in the foundation of cultural and religious systems. This has implications for the study of religion, mythology, and cultural rituals in anthropology and sociology, offering insights into how societies manage violence and create cohesion through shared belief systems and practices.

Girard's work encourages a cross-disciplinary approach, showing that literary theory can inform sociological and anthropological analysis and vice versa. His influence extends into various social science disciplines, prompting researchers to reconsider assumptions about individual autonomy, the origins of conflict, and the role of culture in shaping human behavior.

Discover and learn about people that are similar to René Girard.